The Customer Lifecycle: Why Most Insurance Agencies Stay Stuck in Survival Mode

The Customer Lifecycle: Why Most Insurance Agencies Stay Stuck in Survival Mode

A course this week reminded me of something we all know but rarely implement systematically in our agencies. After 10 years running an independent agency, I'm familiar with the customer lifecycle concept. We all are, right? Get leads, convert them, deliver service, keep clients happy. 

But this week in a business course, the instructor broke down the customer lifecycle in a way that made me realize: I know this framework, but I've never been intentional about applying it to my agency. 

Here's the Framework We Know (But Don't Systematize) 

The course reviewed the 6-step customer lifecycle, and I realized we do all of this - just not intentionally: 

1-4: The Basics

  • Market to Lead: Get the RIGHT leads (multi-policy prospects, not price shoppers) 

  • Lead to Sale: Focus on comprehensive reviews, not quick quotes 

  • Sale to Delivery: Onboarding sets relationship expectations 

  • Delivery to Success: Every service call = coverage review opportunity 

5-6: Where We Get Lazy (The Costly Mistake) 

  • Success to Lead: Turn satisfied clients into systematic referral sources 

  • Success to Market: Capture testimonials and reviews that fuel marketing 

We all get referrals and occasional testimonials, but how many of us have actual systems for this? The instructor's point hit hard: "Most businesses accidentally get results from steps 5-6, but intentional businesses systematize them." 

Why This Matters 

This cycle creates: 

  • Referrals that cost less than cold leads 

  • Multi-policy clients who are more profitable and loyal 

  • Less owner dependency through systematic processes 

My Wake-Up Call 

Looking at my agency honestly, I realized we know this stuff but we're not intentional about it: 

  • We get referrals, but when? How? It's random. 

  • We provide great service, but do we systematically ask for reviews at the right moments? 

  • We have cross-sell opportunities during every service call, but do we consistently identify them? 

The course reminded me: knowing about something and being systematic about it are completely different things. 

What I'm Changing 

I'm not learning new concepts - I'm getting intentional about what I already know: 

  1. Systematic cross-selling - We've started call blocks to reach our monoline book, but we have no system to track if our licensed service team is turning regular service calls into cross-sell opportunities 

  2. Purposeful referral requests - We recently started asking for Google reviews from customers who rate us positively in our NPS surveys, but we're inconsistent about turning those reviews into marketing content 

The difference isn't knowledge - it's intentional implementation and consistent tracking. 

Be honest: Do you know about the customer lifecycle but run your agency on autopilot? Which step are you least intentional about?  

-

Michael Cruz owns an independent insurance agency in Maryland. Follow his journey as he documents building systematic processes in a real agency.